Ways to Add Value to Your Home

Ways to Add Value to Your Home - roomfortuesday.comLet’s talk about getting the biggest bang for your buck when it comes to home repairs and renovating. This is something I’ve surprisingly never addressed on the blog until now- which is crazy because it’s something Emmett and I focus on with every home renovation we complete (from here forward). Click through for tips on adding (and increasing) the value of your home, to see which rooms are smart investments, and why you should always consider the resale value of your home. This post also turned out to be really raw and honest (aka long)– it might also give you some insight into the life that Emmett and I lead and our future plans. 

I’ll start by saying, it was never our intention to “do this”- this being finding the worst home to renovate. We fell in love with the charm and character of our Ohio foreclosure and fell even more in love with the process- so much so, that we literally haven’t stopped renovating and making changes to our home since. Here we are, six years later, in a new state doing the exact same thing and learning new things along the way.

Some people ask if we’re house flippers and the answer is a solid NO… at least at this stage in our career. Although it might look like we’re “flipping” a home, we like to renovate, give a home it’s maximum potential, and enjoy living in it for awhile. Flipping to me is fast and all about the money or profit. That means lots of inexpensive and low quality materials are used to transform the house (although there are exceptions). We’re actually doing just the opposite: we use quality materials that are functional and aesthetically pleasing, and we transform the home to fit the needs of our lifestyle because we always stick around for 3-5 years.

Ways to Add Value to Your Home - roomfortuesday.comIs this our forever home? No, because like I mentioned- we LOVE renovating and this crazy process. I’m also a person who craves change. Emmett is the type of guy who always needs a project, and together- we have a real sense of adventure … moving and starting fresh is exciting to us! Don’t worry, we have plenty left to renovate, love, and live in before we move along to the next, but my point to sharing alllllll of this is to say- this lifestyle we’ve created influences our reno decisions. We have to think about resale value because this isn’t our forever home. I suppose we fall somewhere in the middle of the spectrum…. we don’t flip and use the cheapest materials, we love and appreciate quality (but let’s get real- we’re middle class and certainly not rich), but we are willing to invest in and enjoy our home while we can.

So, what does all of this mean? Every design and material decision we make is based not only our personal preferences, but also on the resale value of our home. If you’re not in your “forever home” you should also be thinking about these things. Hopefully these tips and insight will help you make informed decisions that will eventually pay off when it’s time to sell. I didn’t use to think this way, but being married to Emmett has it’s perks. He does accounting for a living and he’s a total numbers guy. Excel is his jam and when we decided to renovate again, he explained how this time we’d be smarter. It made perfect sense.


H O W    T O    T H I N K    I N     T E R M S    O F    R E S A L E :

Don’t purchase the nicest home on the block. // In fact, we always look for one of the worst. Why? It’s a shame to buy home that’s turnkey, knowing we’ll rip out the perfectly functional kitchen to make it our own. That wouldn’t be a good investment either- especially when we know we can increase the value and totally transform a diamond in the rough.

Invest the smart way. // It seems like if you update a house to the nines and it’s absolutely breathtaking- you should make all of the money you poured into the home back, right? Sadly that’s not true. I sort of learned this the hard way. Not knowing we’d fall in love with renovating and want to do it again, our first home was a true learning experience. I picked out beautiful materials and we renovated without resale in mind. Here’s the thing, if our home was a 10, the majority of our neighbor’s homes were a 3. The neighborhood curb appeal was lacking, they weren’t updated, and the location wasn’t a sought after area. You have to consider the location, the neighborhood, appraisal values, and all sorts of things. In hindsight, I probably shouldn’t have selected an $800 faucet when the home could only sell for so much. No matter how breathtaking and exquisite our house was, it would never sell for double what our neighbor’s homes cost. We pretty much broke even, but we loved that house and it’s finishes- so it’s ok… but we could’ve turned a profit if I would’ve been smarter. It was the perfect learning home.

Ways to Add Value to Your Home - roomfortuesday.comI’ll give you a straight shooter example: let’s say you purchase a home for $100k. Based on market research and appraisals, you think you can someday sell the home for $150k. It would be stupid to spend $80k on upgrades, knowing you’re going to lose $30k. That’s a dumb move, right? You can’t put more into a house than you’ll get back (unless money isn’t an issue for you).

Don’t blow the budget. // Keep records. I cannot reiterate this enough. Emmett keeps a detailed Excel file of every dollar we’ve put into our house and reno. Prior to purchasing, we tried to guesstimate how much would go into each room. Obviously the plan evolves, but if we only have $30k to put into the kitchen, that’s it. Once it’s gone, there’s no more buying this and that. We could “borrow” money from another room- like my office, but that might mean the office reno never happens. We’re pretty good at planning, but it’s important to stick to the budget if you want to make the money back someday. You don’t want to end up like my example above- I’m sure it’s a bad feeling knowing your hard work, time, effort, and fancy fixtures actually lost you money.

Ask a professional. // Strangely, lots of our friends are real estate agents (if you’re moving to Utah, I’ve got guys.. ha!). We definitely like to pick their brains, stay informed on the market, our neighborhood, and future projections. If they were to tell us to hang onto this house a year or two longer, we would trust them. If they tell us to sell a year early, we’d also listen. We adore our neighborhood and location, so adding on and staying longer is something we fantasize about. You better believe we’ll be asking all of our professional friends to come over before we make the final decision to help us decide if it’s a smart investment. It would be naive of us to add a garage and master suite (no matter how badly we want it), if we’ll never recoup the cost. Again- you don’t want to be the nicest / biggest home on the block if you’re thinking in terms of resale because the value of your neighbor’s property will influence your own (hopefully it would increase the value of your home).


W H E R E    S H O U L D    Y O U    P U T    Y O U R    M O N E Y ?

This might seem like a given, but you’ll get the biggest bang for your buck by spending the majority of your budget on the kitchen and bathrooms, closely followed by the master suite. I’m guessing 90% of us have a budget to stick to when it comes to our homes. If you only have so much to spend, spend it here:

Ways to Add Value to Your Home - roomfortuesday.comThe Kitchen // A renovated and updated kitchen is so appealing to buyers. Whether you only update the appliances, or go all out and redo every single thing (like us), every little upgrade is a good investment.

The Bath // Bathrooms should be high on your renovating or updating list. New plumbing fixtures and tile go a long way in terms of resale.

The Master Suite // Mather suites are so convenient and obviously sought after. If you have a large master bedroom, it might be worth making it smaller to add an attached bath- or renovating the existing master suite altogether.

Above all, keep quality in mind. I’d rather see two totally transformed rooms that every single room with terrible materials that weren’t installed properly.


T H E    D E S I G N   S T R U G G L E

Keeping resale value in mind certainly influences my design process and selections. Thinking of our home in a business sense might seem odd to some, but it’s honestly incredibly smart. Having budget parameters helps me narrow down the vast array of products on the market. It also presents a fun design challenge for making things look higher end than they actually are. Challenge accepted (obviously)! That’s always my goal and that’s what will help us gain a return on our investment. However- it’s not always peachy and presents certain things I struggle with…

Ways to Add Value to Your Home - roomfortuesday.com

Creativity // This is the most difficult part for me when designing with resale in mind. It means I can’t go as wild as my brain would like. I try to get weird with paint colors (because those can easily be changed), but when it comes to permanent fixtures and materials- like tile, stone, flooring, sinks, vanity, faucets, etc… I have to keep it appealing to a wide range of people. It’s a delicate balance to keep it well designed, within our budget, keep an eye on quality, as well as make a space unique enough to stand out and be innovative, yet appealing to buyers. I’m not sure if that makes you guys like me more or less? Ha! I’d like to get wild, crazy, and weird… but since I’m not made of money, resale is definitely a big factor that comes into play. If you think my aesthetic is too tame, it reflects our current business model. It’s almost like designing for a client!

I will say- occasionally there are items we want or just have to have that aren’t practical in terms of resale, but if we’re living here for 3-5 years, they’re worth it to us.

The Guts // I refer to the portion of the budget that goes toward fixing things that typically go unnoticed as “the guts”. We’ve spent an insane amount of money on things that the average buyer won’t even notice (in both of our renovations): updated plumbing, electrical, insulation, sod, windows, roofing, etc. I could go on and on. Sometimes it’s disheartening to spend so much on things that aren’t pretty, but they’re very important. While they may or may not add value to the home, Emmett and I have always vowed to renovate the right way… from the inside out. We take our time and make sure everything is safe, to code, and permitted.

The buyers who purchased our Ohio home were SO appreciative. We handed them a a giant binder full of paperwork, permits, paint colors, instruction manuals, warranties, etc. It made us feel good that they valued our hard work; they also promised to upkeep and care for the home like it deserves. That seriously gives me the warm and fuzzies inside, and when I’m back in Ohio, doing a creepy drive-by, I’m comforted knowing that it looks amazing, is appreciated, and the exterior is still well manicured. We created a place we adored, and now a new family is loving it just as much… that’s special!

When It’s Time // I’ll have to devote an entire post to prepping your home to sell. I did want to quickly say, when the time comes, there is definitely a list of “makeunders”, as I like to call them, that need to happen. Sometimes we’ll touch-up paint, stage the home differently for showings, remove personal items, tone down funky decor, textiles, or paint palettes. Basically we want to make it look appealing for the the most inhabitants. We also “de-dog” (another term of mine) the entire house, removing evidence that two crazy pups rule the roost. In this home, I’m pretty sure we’ll have to skip that step because we’re planning built-in dog crates for the laundry room and that’s a permanent architectural feature (another time resale went out the window). Doesn’t everyone in America have a dog these days? Ha! If not, we can’t be friends…. they make life better and buyers will have to deal with that (and my dog-friendly attitude).


O U R    F U T U R E

If you’re wondering about the personal stuff… I’ll close by saying: this is our current outlook- renovate the right way, enjoy the home for a handful of years, and get excited for the next big adventure. I’m not saying we’ll never “flip” a house on the side (it’s actually one of Emmett’s dreams)… but I hope we’re the exception who do it the right way when the time comes.

Ways to Add Value to Your Home - roomfortuesday.comWe also dream about buying a fixer upper CAMPER. I mean, we live in Utah… one of the most breathtaking states in the country. We both decided we’re “outgrowing” tent camping and the dogs would be easier in a camper. Maybe someday we can save up and document that process. Doesn’t it sound fun? Sharing our adventures from our home away from home? That’s a totally different ballgame, and I personally don’t think it’s a great investment- but it would be FUN. It’d make the guy very very happy; anything for him.

We’ve also discussed the dream to renovate a “vacation home”… perhaps a beach cottage or a cabin tucked away in the mountains. We’re not even remotely close to having enough money to do something like that, and we’ve vowed to tackle one complete reno at a time, but the vision makes me giddy with excitement. Someday, maybe we can swing it!

Eventually, we’d like to build a forever home. I’m sure we have years decades ahead of us before we even begin that conversation, but we like dreaming of the possibilities. That’d be the place we could make for us…. it could be weird, out there, personal, and ours to imagine. However, we have plenty of places to travel before we decide where it will be.

That’s pretty much my thoughts on resale, doing our best not to go under while renovating (and doing what we love), as well as the glimmer that is our hopeful future. I’d love to hear your thoughts and feedback! Was that post way too long and now you have zero effort to comment? Sorry guys!! xo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. Ahh thank you! This post is exactly what I needed. Our farm house needs lots of TLC but now that a lovely highway was approved for our neighboring field, I’m not sure if we will be here for the long run.
    I love when your posts are longer :)

    1. So happy it was helpful, Whitney! Sorry to hear about the highway being approved. Emmett and I both grew up on farms and know how that goes. I think you’re one of the few who don’t get bored with the super long and wordy posts ;) Thanks for sticking it through! xox

  2. Great thoughts and advice… thank you!

    1. Thanks for reading, Jen! xox

  3. Michelle @ And Then We Tried says:

    I struggle with the balance of designing my house for resale vs. for me. I’m in my first house that I own and got so excited with the freedom of it that I painted my bedroom floor a dark purple BECAUSE I COULD. I can always paint it white or something less ‘creative’ when I go to sell, but I also just really like picking out things for me. My kitchen renovations have all been phase 1 temporary fixes for now, but when I go to really sink some money into it, I’ll definitely have to keep resale in mind. Having a really old house and trying to keep the updates in line with the character of the home keeps me in check, too!

    1. It’s definitely a delicate balance, Michelle. You’re right though.. have an a historic home certainly helps make the design process and selection easier. Good luck with your renovation! xo

  4. Marti | Project Palermo says:

    I loved this post! The one thing I really struggle with in the renovation of my house is the risk of putting too much money into it, given our neighborhood. Most of our surrounding houses are currently 3s, like you say. Our house might be our forever house, but I am still being mindful of how much I invest in it (e.g. I recently decided to do a make-it-work kitchen makeover instead of a full renovation).

    It’s hard in super competitive markets like Chicago. Fixer-uppers in nicer neighborhoods are sold as tear-downs to developers who build mini-McMansions, which prices people like me out of the “worst house on the best block” opportunity.

    Anyway – thanks for sharing your thoughts! It’s fun to know what your future plans are.

    1. I can relate, Marti! The Salt Lake market is exactly the same… it’s super competitive, has an inventory problem, and investors are scooping up the deals. We got lucky with our house. Good luck with your kitchen makeover! I’m sure it will be amazing. xox

  5. Cathy | the Grit and Polish says:

    Yes, yes, yes! Loved this post Sarah! I so appreciated hearing about the money side of your renovations/resell. I too am an Excel lover and keep track of every dollar we put in our renovations – dollars we think hard about spending in the first place – because our houses have always been investments (well not our forever home, but all the rest). And your post got me thinking more about the responsibility we bloggers have to not just put up pretty photos but also talk about what renovations cost. I’m not sure what the right way to address that is exactly but I don’t want to encourage unattainable expectations or financial irresponsibility. It’s far too easy to be enamored with beautiful interiors via Pinterest and Instagram and think that we too need a La Conche range when in all likelihood you’ll never see that money back in resell. Great post!

    1. So happy to hear this, Cathy! I couldn’t agree more. I always try to be transparent and share a budget breakdown of every project. I feel like I was so naive with our first renovation because I also fell prey to the beauty of Pinterest, Instagram, and print magazines. I guess I thought I’d put every single thing I love into the house and get it all back someday / find a buyer who also loves everything and is willing to pay the price (even if the home didn’t appraise for that much), ha! It was definitely stupidity and I’m hoping this will resonate and help people avoid making the same mistake. xox

  6. Genevieve says:

    Great post, thanks! I think we have found our forever home… But you never know where life will take you, so we are trying to be smart about it. What are your thoughts on basement renovation? It’s such a big project, turn a mostly unfinished basement into a usable space. We feel we would gain a lot of usability but the cost is enormous… And kitchen and bathrooms are outdated! Thanks!

    1. Way to be smart about it, Genevieve! I like your mindset. In your scenario, without a doubt, I would tackle the kitchen and bath renovations on the main floor FIRST. If you have funds leftover for the basement, I’d speak with a professional or find comps in your neighborhood that have finished basements and see how much value it added to their space. Basements can be tricky due to building codes. Depending on the ceiling height, access (windows & doors), and drainage, it may or may NOT count toward the living space square footage. It’d be terrible to dump a bunch of money into a beautiful basement only to list the home someday and realize you can’t count the extra bedroom, bath, etc… toward “living space”. That was a long winded answer to say- do your homework / research in your city, township, state, etc. Hope this helps!! xox

  7. Both of our homes were the cheapest on the block. I was worried but my husband told me that was key! Our second home is 100 years old and so much work and we’re not sure if it’s our forever home. But we love our neighborhood so much that you’d have to drag us out by our hair. Meanwhile, a contractor broke my pedestal sink and chipped our tub this week. This project is lingering and has put some tension in our relationship. But we’re making it through …….one step at a time. I’m starting to get home remodel burnout.

    1. Sounds like you’re being very smart about your renovation, Brandi. Hang in there with the contractors… it will all be worth it when it’s done. There are definitely challenges when working with your spouse on something stressful and important- like remodeling. One step at time! xox

  8. I love all your informative posts! I wish we could be like you guys- unfortunately I’m deisgn obsessed but terrible at decision making and my hubby can’t hang a picture straight 😂 We just moved into our forever home and have the hardest time being patient. We have done a ton of work to the exterior already and we’re about to build a mudroom/laundry in our garage (still room for van + tooks though). It’s on of those big investments that may not add value to our home- but we have 5 kids and a mudroom is imperative in this season of our lives! Praying it turns out beautifully! In the meantime, I’ve read your whole blog for tips and advice!

    1. So happy you liked it, Tamsen! Patience is tough for me too… unfortunately, you need a lot of it while renovating. Ha! Good luck with your mudroom / laundry space- I’m sure it will be beautiful! xo

  9. Rachael KIstler says:

    This was so helpful, Sarah! My husband and I just purchased a home to renovate, live in for awhile, and then turn into an Airbnb/rental. . . and this post was so important for me to read at this moment in time. Even though my heart wants honed Carrera marble counters in the kitchen, it’s stupid to put that kind of money into a home that will be a rental. Thank you for your honesty and candor!

    1. So glad to hear you found it helpful! I used to have a totally different mindset, and I’m so glad Emmett talked some financial sense into me. Ha! Carrera certainly wouldn’t be ideal for a rental- no matter how pretty it is. The fun challenge will be finding a solution that looks just a great, fits the budget, and is durable! Maybe checkout some quartz products. Good luck! xox

  10. This was such a helpful post! It definitely wasn’t too long, ether! We are renovating a possible forever home and I’m afraid I’ve gone a little overboard. I’m going to talk to a realtor and make sure we’re in the right range. Thank you for opening my eyes!

    1. Definitely a smart idea, Paige! Even if it is your forever home, you never know what the future holds… better safe than sorry. I’m happy the post came at an appropriate time for your reno :)

  11. Great post! This question may be too personal, and if so I understand, but I’m wondering- how do most people finance their renovations? Save up and pay cash for all the updates, or finance with a loan? And with a loan- up front with the purchase of the house or a separate one down the road? Lastly, can this only be done if you’re handy enough to diy most things, or if you have no experience with that, can it be done by being your own general contractor and finding reasonable bids? Just curios about the nuts and bolts. Thank you!

    1. Good question, Sarah! I’m all about being 100% honest- so I’m happy to get personal. Everyone has their own financial plan when it comes to renovating. We’re the type that save and pay for the updates as they happen (Emmett is big on not having lots of debt). Like most couples, we applied for a home loan to purchase our house… it’s just for the house only though- no updates. I also have my father to thank for giving us a small head start in the right direction… he passed away of cancer, but luckily had his ducks in a row, so I inherited a tiny bit that we put toward our first home and renovation. Without his planning, it probably would’ve taken us longer to commit to buying our first home years ago. If we end up adding onto our home down the road, we’ll definitely need to apply for a loan and use that money to move forward with the addition- just because that’s a GIANT project we’re not able to fund with cash. I hope that helps! I think the moral is… do what works best for you! We also meet with a financial advisor that also helps direct our endeavors. xo

  12. Julie Marquez says:

    Thanks for sharing this article. Real estate and home renovations are huge costs and I don’t want to see anyone lose money in this hobby just because it looks pretty in pictures or to name drop big brands. Thanks for sharing the financial side because it’s real.

    1. So happy you found value in it! It might be the most important part of a renovation and it’s never discussed. Hopefully others will begin talking more about it. xo

  13. Sarah, I am LOVING your blog! I honestly feel like I could have written this post myself. My husband and I have almost the exact same attitudes and goals as you when it comes to our homes, and I just loved reading this! We also have two dogs, so basically I feel like we’re kinda the same person. ;)

    1. Thank you so much, Jamie (aka, twin) Haha! So happy you’re finding some good content that is relatable- really glad you’re here :) xox

  14. Rose Petrini says:

    Hi Sarah,
    First off… you are doing such an amazing job!! Love your blog!! I am currently looking at putting my house on the market.. my struggle is prepping the house.. we painted the entire house last year.. the issue is half of the house has carpet.. it does cover a large area and it is blue… yuck! It needs to go… there are hard wood floors underneath “yay” although the finish is a reddish brown.. my thought is just rip out the carpet and purchase area rugs from my local pottery barn outlet.. I want to leave refinishing the floors to the new buyer.. the other half of the house had been renovated and new hardwood was installed so the 2 woods wont match. I am having anxiety because I feel like my house needs to look like a page from house beautiful before its on the market
    And i feel like i will never get there! Let me know your thoughts
    Appreciate you!!! 😊

    1. Thank you, Rose! Personally, I would rip up the carpet and throw down some rugs. I like your idea of leaving the floor refinishing to the new homeowners… especially if they’re in good shape (just not an attractive color). It would be a better use of your funds. No need to have anxiety! Believe me when I say, your house does not need to look like it came from a magazine before listing. Check out my easy tips for staging your home to sell (quickly): https://roomfortuesday.com/staging-your-home-to-sell/ You can do it!! :)